The Threat of QAnon
Source: Getty Images
How Domestic Disinformation Campaigns are Seeking to Infiltrate Mainstream Political Discourse
What is QAnon?
- QAnon started as a far-right fringe conspiracy theory on the anonymous internet forum 4chan, but is now a growing cult-like movement threatening to infiltrate mainstream political discourse.
- “QAnon” refers to both the American government informant who purported to have access to classified information involving the Trump administration, and who first posted content anonymously under the moniker “Q” in 2017; AND the conspiracy and political movement that resulted thereafter.
- Broadly speaking, the conspiracy alleges that a cabal of Satan-worshiping pedophiles who run a global sex-trafficking ring are secretly plotting against President Trump. The supposed cabal includes top donors and leaders in the Democrat party, members of the media, prominent politicians like the Clintons, among other members of the political establishment. The first post made by “Q,” on 4chan, an anonymous internet message board where conspiracy theories abound, claimed to have evidence in support of the conspiracy, quickly expanded across multiple media platforms where it built a large following, and where more specific conspiracies flourished as a result.
- QAnon-based conspiracies range from suggestions that the CIA installed North Korean Leader Kim Jong-un as a “puppet-leader,” to the conviction that powerful political figures are plotting a coup against President Trump.
The Great Meme War of 2020
A more problematic outgrowth of the QAnon movement that seeks to wage information warfare during American elections to the benefit of the far-right is taking root across social media platforms.
In a post titled “Meme War 2020” on the anonymous forum 8kun, a successor to 4chan, a QAnon follower outlined the new phase of the movement:
“We need memes that are funny and mocking of the democrat candidates, but also that are informative and revealing about their policies that are WRONG for the United States...We also need memes that are PRO-TRUMP, that explain how his policies are RIGHT for the United States...and that can debunk the smears and attacks that are no doubt going to come at POTUS..again, and again.”
The U.S. House voted to condemn QAnon and “reject the conspiracy theories it promotes” after the FBI warned that the movement’s conspiracy theories fuel domestic terrorism such as the series of violent clashes between protestors and counter-protesters in American cities this year. The FBI outlined the concerns in a document in May 2019:
“The FBI assesses these conspiracy theories very likely will emerge, spread, and evolve in the modern information marketplace, occasionally driving both groups and individual extremists to carry out criminal or violent acts.” It also goes on to say the FBI believes conspiracy theory-driven extremists are likely to increase during the 2020 presidential election cycle.”
FBI Director Christopher Wray said the biggest concern related to security of the 2020 Presidential Election is “the steady drumbeat of misinformation and...amplification of smaller cyber intrusions.” And that increased volume and reach of conspiratorial content due to social media enables a “crowd-sourcing” effect where “conspiracy theory followers themselves shape a given theory by presenting information that supplements, expands, or localizes its narrative.”
According to Wray, the QAnon movement operates as a large network of individual factions due to different orientations and goals, but the output of individuals nodes, or groups, in the QAnon network follow a similar theme, that is, nationalism and hyperpartisanship against the Democratic party.
An expert studying the proliferation of QAnon sub-communities on social media stated the platforms are “an essential piece of the infrastructure” holding the groups together, and that earlier intervention on part of the Big Tech giants, including Facebook and Twitter, could have prevented QAnon’s widespread internet presence.
Despite concerns raised by government officials over a year and a half prior to the presidential election, Facebook and Twitter were slow to restrict QAnon’s influence across their platforms. The social media giants did not initiate broad crackdowns on QAnon until the summer of 2020, when they shut down more than 20,000 accounts and pages connected to the conspiracy. Youtube removed tens of thousands of QAnon-related videos as part of a broader effort to remove content that violates its hate speech policy in June 2019, still long after the threat of the conspiracy group had been established.
A key factor that prevented a swift purge of the QAnon network on social media is the reluctance of Facebook, Twitter and other Big Tech companies to act as arbiters of the truth, and especially because QAnon is considered authentic domestic political speech. The role social media companies should play in regulating disinformation and harmful conspiracy theories is a long-standing, contentious issue.
Recent action taken by social media platforms against QAnon cite violations of anti-violence policies and the need to “limit the ability of QAnon and Militarized Social Movements to operate and organize” on social media platforms. The crackdown on QAnon is less to do with preventing disinformation than it is to prevent real-world violence.
Memes & the Weaponization of Hashtags
The 2019 Louisiana Gubernatorial Election
How QAnon conspiracists targeted the Louisiana gubernatorial election in late 2019 illustrates how QAnon subcommunities weaponize social media platforms and infiltrate local politics.
In the Louisiana election, QAnon conspiracists hi-jacked social media attention of key hashtags, such as #vote and #JohnBelEdwards, by including the hashtags in a flood of tweets supporting Republican candidates and “memes” that ridiculed Gov. Edwards.
As part of the “Great Meme War of 2020,” QAnon supporters continue to target popular hashtags and spam large audiences of users with disinformation in order to foment public division and shape narratives about political events. Some describe this tactic of coordinated attacks on hashtags as “raiding” or a “hashtag rally.”
On the day of Louisiana's runoff election, Qanon conspiracists “raided” a Twitter thread by the Democratic Governors Association and spammed the post with memes criticizing Edwards and disinformation about his political record.
“Memes” are a key QAnon tactic. Because memes are images, they circumvent efforts by social media platforms to moderate content. The large network of QAnon supporters maintain a stockpile of memes that they regularly tap into during key moments of controversy. QAnon’s strategy is relatively straight forward: followers build lists of hashtags to target, generate content and memes related to current events, and inundate social media with propaganda to derail authentic discussions happening online.
Use of highly-organized strategies allows QAnon supporters to attack individual accounts and online communities with such coordination and consistency. On another occasion, a now-deactivated Facebook page posted step-by-step instructions for followers to participate in “raiding” operations, whereby a page administrator divided followers into teams with different objectives and instructions on when and how to spam posts by important political leaders.
It is difficult to determine how this activity impacted voting, or if it did at all. The goal of QAnon followers is to flood social media with far-right propaganda in an attempt to push radical fringe ideas and information into mainstream political discourse.
A key issue that differentiates QAnon from disinformation campaigns waged by foreign actors is that QAnon followers are, for the most part, real American citizens whose speech is protected under the First Amendment. This represents a new and more problematic phase of information warfare, one in which disinformation campaigns are spawned domestically as well as by our foreign adversaries.
//Page written by: Christina Georgacopoulos